Young, British and Tradwife: documentary on UK tradwives leaves critic wanting more depth
The Guardian's reviewer assesses the documentary Young, British and Tradwife, in which journalist Poppy Jay interviews three British women who promote a traditional housewife lifestyle. The critic finds it provocative but too cautious with its female subjects.

British film-maker and journalist Poppy Jay has made a documentary, Young, British and Tradwife, which The Guardian has now reviewed. It follows her earlier film, Young, British and Anti-Abortion. "Tradwife" refers to a lifestyle in which a wife takes on a traditional homemaker role and defers to her husband. It first spread on social media in the US, where evangelical Christianity and social conservatism, closely tied to it, are stronger influences than in Britain.
In the film, Jay interviews three women in the UK who advocate this way of life. The reviewer says they were chosen to show different forms of the movement.
Three women
Megan is at the gentler end of the spectrum. She reads the Bible's call for wives to be subservient as part of a relationship in which both partners are expected "to lay down your lives for each other". She runs an Instagram account featuring her children and earns money from sponsorship, which is the only way the couple can afford for her to stay at home. Before having children she founded a kombucha business with a friend, then handed the running of it to her husband, Joseph.
Laura Zachary is a born-again Christian who married Zion six months ago and likes to post provocative content. She says the more people disagree with her and engage with her account, the more she gets paid. The reviewer says Jay does not press her on how far this is a business decision.
Molly is a mother of seven and the wife of Aaron, a Christian nationalist theologian. Jay spent a few days living with the couple, and Molly then stayed at Jay's London flat. Molly says she once wanted to be a journalist.
The reviewer's verdict
The reviewer calls the film hugely frustrating, wishing for deeper interviews led by a trained psychotherapist and conversations with relatives and friends. In their view Jay is fearless with the men but perhaps too careful with the women. They note that the movement is starting to fall apart in the US, with high-profile members divorcing and stories of abuse and coercion emerging.


