Estonia debates state plan to build apartments in small towns
Estonia's government plans a pilot project to build about 1,000 apartments in small towns, but businessman Risto Abel argues the state should invest in infrastructure rather than act as a housing developer.

Estonia's Ministry of Climate plans to launch a pilot project next year under which the state would build about 1,000 new apartments in small towns. The plan has drawn criticism: in an opinion piece for ERR News, businessman Risto Abel argues that the problem is real but the solution is wrong, and that the state should build roads and utilities rather than apartments.
What the government plans
Ivo Jaanisoo, the ministry's deputy secretary general, recently said the private sector is not currently building housing in places such as Paide or Põlva. Construction costs there are similar to those in Tallinn, but sale and rental prices are much lower. Under the government's vision, the first apartment buildings could be completed by 2030.
The author's arguments
Abel agrees with the diagnosis: outside the Tallinn and Tartu regions very few new homes are built, even though roughly one-third of Estonia's population lives there. Access to financing is another obstacle, since banks struggle to assess risk when there are few comparable transactions.
In his view, people move to places where jobs exist or where they can reasonably commute to work, not simply where a vacant apartment is available. He cites Kohila, reachable from Tallinn in about half an hour by car or train, as a positive example. Roads, rail, water and sewer systems, high-speed internet, electricity connections and industrial parks, he says, attract employers.
Abel also points to risks: the cost of empty apartments would ultimately fall on taxpayers, and the ministry itself has named who would pay for vacant units as the biggest unanswered question. If municipalities had to guarantee rental income, the money would come from the same budget that funds roads and kindergartens. State-subsidized housing could also make it harder for private developers to compete.
The proposed alternative
The author suggests that the state or local governments prepare building plots by completing detailed planning, utility connections and roads, while private developers build the housing. A starting point could be the 100 plots municipalities have already proposed for the ministry's project. He also backs the Rural Development Foundation's program that helps people buy, build or renovate homes in rural areas even when banks decline to lend because of low collateral values.

/nginx/o/2023/09/08/15576946t1h3ad6.jpg)
