San Diego drops both Flock cameras and smart streetlights
At its Monday meeting, the San Diego city council in the US rejected the Flock license plate reader camera program and the linked Ubicquia smart streetlights. Both were backed by the mayor and police when approved in 2023.
The city council of San Diego, California, voted at its Monday meeting to abandon automatic license plate reader cameras from the company Flock, along with the Ubicquia smart streetlights that operated alongside them. The decision ends a surveillance system built on AI-driven software that the city installed in 2023 with police support.
Police arguments
At the meeting, police representatives said vehicle theft has fallen 20 percent since 2023 and that 689 stolen vehicles were recovered thanks to the Flock cameras. Three years ago, the mayor and other municipal leaders urged the council to approve the program, which makes the current vote a sharp reversal.
A second retreat from smart streetlights
This is the second time in under a decade that San Diego has tried smart streetlight technology and then dropped it. The city had earlier bought thousands of such systems from a different vendor, GE Current, but a previous mayoral administration shut them down in 2020. Ubicquia later acquired the smart city platform and, in partnership with Flock, proposed a new installation of 500 cameras in 2023, which police supported.
At that time, the City of San Diego Privacy Advisory Board, a local watchdog body, asked the council to vote the plan down. Board member Pegah Parsi wrote on LinkedIn that she now feels vindicated, urging cities and institutions to listen earnestly to the expert advisory boards they create.
A wider pattern
Secure Justice, an Oakland-based advocacy group that studies and monitors Flock's problems across the United States, says it has documented at least 513 Flock contracts that have ended, in both Republican- and Democratic-leaning states and in large and small cities. The group's executive director, Brian Hofer, told Ars Technica that Americans, in his view, do not consent to their government tracking them in daily life.


