Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Rīga TV

World and Latvian news in one place

AgriculturePublished: 17 November 2026 at 06:01

German court rules farmer's land transfer to daughters is a farm break-up

A Münster tax court in Germany held that a farmer's transfer of her land to two daughters amounted to breaking up the farm, not a transfer at book value. The case is now before the Federal Fiscal Court.

Foto: agrarheute (Vācija)

A dispute over how tax applies to a German farmer's transfer of land to her heirs has reached the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH), Germany's top court for tax matters. The Münster Fiscal Court earlier found that by dividing her land between her two daughters, the woman had in effect wound up her farm, so tax is due on the increase in the land's value. The case matters to farmers planning to pass holdings to their children.

What happened

The farmer had inherited the land from her late husband and leased it out, no longer farming it herself. For tax purposes it was a dormant farm of about 40,000 square metres. By notarial contract she gave all the plots to her two daughters as an advance on their inheritance, counted against any potential compulsory-portion claims. One daughter declared herself settled and waived further claims.

The tax office concluded that the farm had not been passed intact to a single successor, so it could not be transferred at book values. It treated the case as a break-up of the farm and taxed the amount by which market values exceeded book values as a private withdrawal. The income tax assessment included a withdrawal gain of 274,000 euros.

The dispute

The farmer argued that each daughter received more than 3,000 square metres, meaning a partial farm had been transferred. In her view, only the land given to the second daughter as compensation should be taxed, while the reduced remaining farm continued with the first daughter. She also said she wanted to keep the farm in the family and avoid conflict between her daughters.

The court rejected these arguments. It held that a farm is given up when all its agricultural land is transferred to third parties, whereas simply shrinking a farm is not a cessation. Where land is split among several heirs who are not business partners, the farm is considered broken up. Because the criteria separating a break-up from a downsizing have not been sufficiently settled at the highest level, the court allowed an appeal to the BFH, where the case is pending under reference VI R 24/19.

Comments

0/1500

Comments are automatically moderated. No hate, threats, personal data or spam.

Loading comments…

More in this category