Victorian Greens seek court injunction over independent's how-to-vote cards imitating party branding
Australia's Victorian Greens are asking the state Supreme Court to stop independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan distributing how-to-vote cards that imitate the party's branding but rank it last. The judge adjourned the case until Saturday.

The Victorian Greens, a minor political party in the Australian state of Victoria, are seeking an urgent Supreme Court injunction to stop independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan from distributing how-to-vote cards that the party says imitate its branding while urging voters to put the Greens last. The dispute concerns the Prahran seat in the state election, where early in-person voting (prepoll) opened on Wednesday morning.
The card
Finnigan's campaign team handed out cards using the Greens' colour scheme, font and triangle logo, under the banner "Vote 1 Green Values". The card asked voters to put Finnigan first, then an Animal Justice Party candidate, another independent, and the Liberals fourth, which would ultimately benefit the Liberals.
The Greens want to win back the ultra-marginal seat they lost to the Liberals at a February 2025 byelection by a 1.3% margin. Labor is running an open ticket in Prahran, which the Greens fear could deprive them of needed preference votes.
Legal steps
On Wednesday the Greens' state director, Martin Shield, asked Finnigan to stop distributing the material immediately and threatened legal action if no undertaking was given within two hours. Finnigan agreed and within hours produced a revised card with different colours and the banner "Vote 1 Trans Greens Values", plus a disclaimer that he is not an endorsed Greens candidate. The Greens were not satisfied, and on Friday afternoon their lawyers lodged papers in the Supreme Court.
At the first hearing on Friday night, the Greens' lawyer, Adam McBeth, alleged Finnigan's handout staff wore the exact shade of green worn by genuine Greens volunteers and stood next to them. Finnigan, who represented themselves, denied instructing the team to stand beside the Greens and said the colour was chosen because it is called "Irish green" and they have Irish background. They also said there was not enough money to print new cards.
Justice John Watson said the first card "looked like a pretty deliberate attempt to pass yourself off as a Greens candidate", but adjourned the matter until 3pm Saturday to hear testimony from the Victorian Election Commission (VEC). The VEC accepted and published Finnigan's second card on Friday evening.

