Scientists: "Race realism" is not science, and genetics does not support it
Researchers writing in Ars Technica argue that modern genetics does not back claims of innate racial differences in intelligence. They point to flaws in the methods and data used by so-called race science.

Modern genetics, evolutionary biology and psychology do not support claims that races differ innately in intelligence, according to researchers writing in the science outlet Ars Technica. Their analysis comes as racial views of human nature are re-emerging in Western politics.
The authors note that at this year's World Economic Forum in Davos, US President Donald Trump said Somalis are "low-IQ people". His son, Donald Trump Jr., made a similar remark about Haitians in 2024. The authors say such narratives feed far-right propaganda and social media misinformation strategies.
The genetics argument
The researchers recall that evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin showed in the 1970s that there is more genetic variation within human groups than between them. They say this conclusion still holds today. Ancient DNA research points to constant mixing between populations during waves of migration, which makes ideas of genetic "purity" meaningless.
Problems with IQ data
Supporters of so-called race science rely heavily on the "national IQ" database. According to the authors, researchers have repeatedly shown it to be methodologically flawed, since intelligence cannot be measured the same way across very different cultures with different access to education. The Flynn effect, a rise in IQ scores through the 20th and 21st centuries, indicates that scores are strongly shaped by environment.
History and publishing
The authors recall that early in the 20th century race science was mainstream and underpinned eugenics, including forced sterilization. It lost standing after the Second World War. In the 1960s, however, the journal Mankind Quarterly became a venue for its supporters, funded by the Pioneer Fund, set up in the 1930s. The authors say race science rarely appears in genetics or biology journals but is published in para-scientific outlets and a few mainstream academic ones.
