Monday, 16 November 2026
Rīga TV

World and Latvian news in one place

WorldPublished: 16 November 2026 at 20:03

Zoe Williams: refugees are rarely portrayed as fully human in the media

Guardian columnist Zoe Williams, writing after a screening of a documentary about four refugees, argues that refugees in news coverage are usually cast as victims, criminals or heroes rather than complex individuals.

Foto: Guardian Ukraina

Zoe Williams, a columnist for the British newspaper The Guardian, argues in a commentary that media and political debate rarely present refugees as whole people with personalities, strength, trauma and humour. Her piece was prompted by a screening last week of the documentary "Seize the Summit", after which she chaired a panel discussion. The screening was organised by Hanya, a recent MA graduate of Goldsmiths, University of London.

A film about four refugees

The film, directed by Arwa Damon, follows four refugees as they try to climb Mount Kilimanjaro: Shaqayeq from Afghanistan, Adnan and Safa from Syria, and Tania from Ukraine. According to Damon, the film is not about war and displacement but about nature and recovery. Safa does not reach the summit because severe burn injuries have affected her breathing. Adnan, who was shot by a sniper at the age of 14 and has lost the use of his body from the chest down, does not make it to the top either; Williams writes that his journey is above all about struggling to accept help.

The columnist's argument

Williams says refugees tend to be sorted into categories: the helpless victim, the criminal, the hero (usually in retrospective accounts by the children of refugees), or a faceless mass discussed only as a burden on host states. In her view, the status of child refugees is contested, while male refugees are being erased from the public imagination altogether. A female refugee, she writes, is allowed to be sad but not angry.

Panellist Ronan Toal, a human rights barrister, noted that the Somali word for claiming asylum is "surrender". Hanya, who is from Gaza, said the one thing refugees are not allowed is a sense of humour. Williams notes that the climbers in the film laugh a lot, which she describes as a story about human beings rather than one of heroism.

Comments

0/1500

Comments are automatically moderated. No hate, threats, personal data or spam.

Loading comments…

More in this category