WSJ: US Discusses Ukraine's NATO Membership in Exchange for Donbas
US officials have floated the idea that Ukraine could join NATO if it cedes all of Donbas to Russia, The Wall Street Journal reported on 19 November, citing sources familiar with the talks.

US representatives have proposed, in talks with European officials on ending the war in Ukraine, that Ukraine join NATO, the Western military alliance, in exchange for handing Donbas to Russia. This would include territory that Kyiv still controls. The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reported this on 19 November, citing sources familiar with the negotiations.
What has been discussed
According to the paper, the idea has been discussed in recent months by US presidential special envoy Steve Witkoff and Donald Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner. It was last raised last week in Dublin, at a meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and national security advisers from European countries. The proposal was also discussed at no fewer than one meeting in the United Arab Emirates attended by Ukrainian, European and Russian negotiators.
The WSJ describes two possible scenarios. In the first, Ukraine would give up the part of Donbas it still holds in return for full NATO membership. In the second, the conflict would be frozen along the current front line, leaving part of Donbas under Kyiv's control. Security guarantees for Ukraine would then rest on a treaty with the US and possibly European allies.
A US official told the paper that many ideas are under discussion and that a final agreement would require the consent of both Ukraine and Russia.
Positions of the sides
The WSJ notes it is unclear how seriously Washington is considering the proposal, or whether Trump has changed his stance. Early last year he called Ukraine's NATO membership unacceptable to Russia.
Zelensky confirmed that the issue had come up in the talks. According to him, the American side asked what would happen if Ukraine joined NATO: would it give up Donbas? Zelensky has repeatedly said Ukraine does not intend to surrender its territory and that any agreement must be approved by the Ukrainian people.
Moscow's position is the opposite. According to a document setting out the Russian negotiators' position, which the WSJ has seen, Russia demands that Ukraine's NATO aspiration be removed from its constitution. It also insists the alliance commit not to station troops or military equipment on Ukrainian territory, and that deliveries of Western weapons end. Russia further demands that NATO's military infrastructure in Eastern Europe be returned to its 1997 level. European negotiators described these demands as maximalist opening proposals.
Obstacles within NATO
Divisions within NATO are an additional obstacle, since enlargement requires the unanimous consent of all members. French President Emmanuel Macron said after talks in Berlin on 18 November that it was time to discuss Ukraine's NATO membership. German representatives were not ready to back the idea, and Chancellor Friedrich Merz, according to the paper, told aides he does not expect Ukraine to join the alliance in his lifetime.

